In a setback for special counsel Jack Smith, the U.S. Supreme Court on Friday turned down his request for a fast-track ruling on whether former President Trump may be prosecuted for having allegedly conspired to block then-President-elect Biden from being certified as the winner of the 2020 election.
Without comment or dissent, the justices denied Smith’s request.
The D.C. Circuit Court has said it will consider the issue in early January, but the high court’s action is likely to delay a final resolution of the legal question.
Trump’s lawyers said the criminal charges should be thrown out on the grounds that a former president cannot be charged with a crime for his “official acts” while in the White House.
But the special counsel said ex-presidents do not enjoy “absolute immunity” for past crimes, and he urged the justices to rule quickly on the issue so Trump’s trial can begin March 4.
In his appeal seeking a quick ruling, Smith did not mention the election year calendar or Trump’s standing as the front-runner for the Republican presidential nomination. But many conservatives and Trump supporters said the Biden administration and the special counsel waited two years to bring a criminal prosecution and they bear the responsibility for any delays now.
The immunity claim is one of two major legal questions involving Trump’s conduct after losing the 2020 election that could have a significant impact on his bid to reclaim the presidency next year.
The justices are likely to be asked soon to rule on whether Trump can be disqualified and removed from the ballot for having “engaged in insurrection,” a violation of the 14th Amendment.
Trump’s lawyers are expected to appeal a decision of the Colorado Supreme Court that would remove Trump from the primary ballot there.
The special counsel did not charge Trump with inciting an insurrection. Instead, he indicted the former president with defrauding the United States and voters and with conspiring to obstruct an official proceeding.
The Constitution does not say directly whether a president can be prosecuted for crimes after leaving office, nor has the Supreme Court ruled on the issue. That’s because no prior president has been indicted for crimes.
The impeachment clauses say a president can be removed from office if two-thirds of the Senate votes to convict him of treason, bribery or “other high crimes and misdemeanors.” Trump was impeached twice by the House, but not convicted by the Senate.
In February 2021, 57 senators voted to convict him for inciting an insurrection that led to the mob attack on the Capitol, but 67 votes were required for a conviction. That verdict could have disqualified Trump from holding office again.
While impeachment is not a criminal proceeding, the Constitution says “the party convicted shall nevertheless be liable and subject to indictment, trial, judgment and punishment, according to law.”
The special counsel says that provision confirms that a president or any other high official may be prosecuted for a crime after an impeachment.
Trump’s lawyers argue the reverse. They say that because the former president was not a “party convicted” in his second impeachment trial, he cannot be indicted and tried for the same charges now.
The closest Supreme Court precedent on presidential immunity involved President Nixon, but not for the more famous dispute over the Watergate tapes. Four years after he left office, Nixon was sued by a Pentagon whistleblower who was dismissed in 1970 for having revealed huge cost overruns.
In Nixon vs. Fitzgerald, the high court ruled in a 5-4 vote that “a former president of the United States is entitled to absolute immunity from damages liability predicated on his official acts.”
The majority said this shield from lawsuits is based “on the president’s unique office and is rooted in the constitutional tradition of the separation of powers.”
Writing in dissent, Justice Byron White questioned how far such a ruling could extend. If the principle of presidential immunity is based on the Constitution, he said, it would mean Congress “cannot provide a remedy against presidential misconduct, and the criminal laws of the United States are wholly inapplicable to the president. … I find this approach completely unacceptable,” adding it “places the president above the law.”
Reach Out
Don’t hesitate to reach out to us to discuss your specific needs. Our team is ready and eager to provide you with tailored solutions that align with your firm’s goals and enhance your digital marketing efforts. We look forward to helping you grow your law practice online.
Our Services:
Blog Post Writing
We do well-researched, timely, and engaging blog posts that resonate with your clientele, positioning you as a thought leader in your domain.
Content Writing
Beyond articles and content for blogs, we delve into comprehensive content pieces like eBooks, and case studies, tailored to showcase your expertise.
Website Content Writing: First impressions matter. Our content ensures your website reflects the professionalism, dedication, and expertise you bring to the table.
Social Media Management
In today’s interconnected world, your online presence extends to social platforms. We help you navigate this terrain, ensuring your voice is consistently represented and heard.
WordPress Website Maintenance
Your digital office should be as polished and functional as your physical one. We ensure your WordPress site remains updated, secure, and user-friendly.
For more information, ad placements in our attorney blog network, article requests, social media management, or listings on our top 10 attorney sites, reach out to us at canyoncrestguide@gmail.com.
Warm regards,
Canyon Crest Guide Newspaper
Whether you’re a startup or an established brand, business directories offer an affordable, yet powerful tool to elevate your brand recognition and reach. Sign up, stand out, and let your business soar to new heights, sign up to one of our directory websites:
Canyon Crest Directory
Riverside Ca Business Directory
The Riverside Coupon Directory
Newspaper Ads Canyon Crest CA
Like us on Facebook Here
Canyon Crest Guide
5225 Canyon Crest Drive Ste.71 #854 Riverside CA 92507
Tony Ramos 951-235-3518
For great backlinks to your website sign up to one of our directory websites:
Canyon Crest Directory
Riverside Ca Business Directory
The Riverside Coupon Directory
Newspaper Ads Canyon Crest CA
Click To See Full Page Ads
Click To See Half Page Ads
Click To See Quarter Page Ads
Click To See Business Card Size Ads
If you have questions before you order, give me a call @ 951-235-3518 or email @ canyoncrestnewspaper@gmail.com
Like us on Facebook Here
Source link
Mayorkas say impeachment effort ‘does not rattle me’
WASHINGTON — This isn’t the kind of history Alejandro Mayorkas wanted to make. The son of...
Behind JuJu Watkins, USC women’s basketball has become ‘the hunted’ – Orange County Register
They danced in the rain on Figueroa Avenue, a throng of trumpets gathering to serenade the...
0 Comments